Every year, the release of the big Christmas adverts becomes something of a national event. We watch them, judge them, share them and, increasingly, argue about them.
This year has been no different.
John Lewis and Marks & Spencer both released their 2026 Christmas adverts last week, and the public reaction has been fascinating. Some people love them. Others think they’ve missed the mark entirely. Social media is full of opinions and the marketing industry has been quick to weigh in.
But perhaps that’s the most interesting thing about it all.
Whether people love an advert or hate it, they’re feeling something. And in a world increasingly dominated by automation, that’s worth paying attention to.
Two Christmas adverts. Two very different reactions.
John Lewis: Gloria and Pickles

John Lewis has built its Christmas advertising reputation on emotional storytelling. This year’s campaign explores the joy of thoughtful gifting through a grandmother, her grandchildren and a childhood toy dog brought to life. You can read about it and watch it on John Lewis’s own site.
Yet the response has been mixed. Some viewers appreciate the sentiment, while others have questioned how relatable the story feels during a cost-of-living crisis.
Marks & Spencer: The Home of Christmas

M&S has taken a different approach, leaning into humour, warmth and festive escapism with James Norton as a rather unconventional Santa. You can watch it on the M&S website.
It’s a lighter take on Christmas, and one that’s resonated strongly with audiences.
The early numbers add a twist. In OnePulse’s launch-day surveys, 74% of viewers liked or loved the M&S advert, which scored 4.0 out of 5, while 68% liked or loved the John Lewis advert, which scored 3.8 out of 5 (OnePulse on M&S, OnePulse on John Lewis). Those are small surveys of around 500 people each, so treat them as a snapshot rather than the final word.
But here’s the question. Is the success of an advert simply about how many people like it?
I’d argue there’s more to it than that.
John Lewis has generated debate, criticism, discussion and countless opinions. M&S has created excitement, amusement and plenty of conversation of its own.
Both have achieved something that many marketing campaigns struggle to do.
They’ve made people stop and react.
Of course, attention alone isn’t enough. An advert can generate plenty of conversation for entirely the wrong reasons. But the reaction to these campaigns reminds us how powerful emotional engagement can be!
Marketing isn’t just about being seen. It’s about being felt.
As marketers, we spend an enormous amount of time thinking about visibility.
Reach, impressions, clicks, conversions, engagement rates. All important, all measurable and all part of understanding whether our marketing is working.
But there’s something that doesn’t fit quite so neatly into a dashboard.
How did it make someone feel?
Did it make them smile or cry? Did it remind them of someone? Did it challenge their thinking, spark curiosity or make them see a brand differently?
And perhaps most importantly, will they remember it tomorrow?
Because the campaigns that stay with us aren’t always the ones with the biggest budgets or the cleverest targeting. They’re the ones that connect with something human.
The one thing AI can’t manufacture: genuine human understanding
We’re working in an industry that’s changing at an extraordinary pace.
AI can generate content, produce imagery, analyse audiences, optimise advertising campaigns and automate processes that once took hours. And there’s no question that these tools have a valuable place in modern marketing. But being able to produce more content doesn’t necessarily mean producing better marketing. AI can recognise patterns in human behaviour. It can analyse emotional language and generate a story designed to provoke a particular response.
What it doesn’t have is the lived experience behind those emotions.
It hasn’t felt the pressure of trying to create the perfect Christmas for your family. It doesn’t know what it’s like to miss someone at Christmas, to laugh at a shared family joke or to feel that sudden rush of nostalgia when a familiar song plays. It can model those experiences, but it doesn’t live them.
And that difference matters.
The creative judgement to recognise which human experiences are worth exploring, how they might resonate with a particular audience and when a message feels authentic rather than manufactured remains incredibly valuable.
AI can help us create the work. But human insight is what gives that work meaning. We have written before about what AI has really changed in Google and Meta advertising, and the same rule applies: it is a powerful tool, not a substitute for thinking.
Not everyone has to love your marketing
One of the most interesting lessons from this year’s Christmas adverts is that even the biggest brands, with substantial budgets, experienced creative teams and extensive consumer research, can’t guarantee a universally positive response.
And perhaps they shouldn’t try to.
Marketing that attempts to appeal to absolutely everyone can end up saying very little to anyone. That doesn’t mean deliberately creating controversy or ignoring your audience. It means understanding that strong creative ideas sometimes provoke different reactions.
What feels heartwarming to one person might feel sentimental to another. What one audience finds funny, another might find irritating. The important thing is knowing who you’re trying to reach, what matters to them and what you want them to take away. An emotional response is valuable, but it needs to serve the brand and its objectives. If your message is not landing, our post on why a perfect marketing message can still fail is a good place to start.
After all, being talked about and being trusted aren’t necessarily the same thing.
What does this mean for the rest of us?
Most businesses don’t have John Lewis or M&S advertising budgets. They don’t have celebrity casts, elaborate productions or prime-time television slots. But they do have something equally important. People.
Customers with real problems. Employees with stories worth telling. Businesses built on ambition, relationships, expertise and years of hard work.
That’s where meaningful marketing begins.
For an engineering business, it might be the pride behind a complex project. For a healthcare provider, it could be the reassurance of knowing someone is genuinely listening. For a family business, it might be the generations of experience behind what they do. Real customer stories help too, and we explain why in why real life testimonials are essential for your marketing.
The emotion doesn’t have to be dramatic. It doesn’t even have to be sentimental. It might be confidence, relief, excitement, pride, trust or simply the feeling that a business understands you. The challenge is finding that connection and communicating it in a way that feels genuine.
And that takes more than a prompt, a template or an automated content schedule. It takes curiosity, empathy, creativity and an understanding of people.
The future of marketing needs more humanity, not less.
There’s a temptation, as technology makes content creation faster and easier, to focus on producing more.
More posts. More adverts. More emails. More campaigns.
But more isn’t necessarily better. If anything, the sheer volume of content we’re exposed to makes emotional connection more important than ever. The brands that stand out won’t simply be those that adopt the latest technology fastest. They’ll be the ones that use it intelligently without losing sight of the people they’re trying to reach.
This year’s Christmas adverts have reminded us that marketing is still capable of creating a genuine cultural conversation. We might disagree about which advert deserves the Christmas crown. We might love one and dislike the other.
But we’re talking about them. We’re reacting to them. And we’re remembering them.
And that’s the point.
Good marketing should make you feel something. Because if it makes you feel nothing, why would you remember it?
At Staunton Rook, we believe technology should support creativity, not replace the human thinking behind it. Because the best marketing starts with understanding people, not simply producing content.
If you would like help finding the human story in your own business, our team works across marketing planning and brand design, and our AI marketing team uses technology to support the thinking, never to replace it. You can also get in touch for a conversation.
Sources
- John Lewis Partnership, John Lewis unveils its 2026 Christmas advert, launched 3 November 2026.
- M&S, M&S launches The Home of Christmas, launched 6 November 2026.
- OnePulse, Christmas Ad Tracker 2026, including the M&S result.
- OnePulse, John Lewis Christmas Ad 2026 reactions, launch-day survey.
Staunton Rook is a full-service marketing agency based in Chester, working with businesses across the UK.


